A Silk Road Document Based Question:
The Silk Road is a touchstone for world history. It was a rich trans-regional vehicle for the transmission of art, religion, science and disease that also affords a glimpse into the politics and economic systems of the pre-modern world. It is a topic rarely given short shrift by instructors and a rich source for student scholarship and learning. So rich, that few students are likely to consider a document-based question on the subject a shot in the dark, and they are thus more likely to be able to apply the analytical skills that are a necessary component of secondary and post-secondary courses in world history and also for the development of life-long learning that is the ultimate goal of public education.
The following question will be instantly recognizable to instructors of Advanced Placement World History, but will not be seen as alien to any world history classroom format. The time limitations are suitable to other formats, such as a college-level final examination.
The Silk Road in World History
Directions: The following question is based on the accompanying Sources 1 - 6. (The sources have been edited for the purpose of this exercise).
The question is designed to test your ability to work with and understand historical sources. Write an essay that:
· Has a relevant thesis and supports that thesis with evidence from the sources.
· Uses all of the sources.
· Analyzes the sources by grouping them in as many appropriate ways as possible. Does not simply summarize the sources individually.
· Takes into account both the sources of the documents and the authors' points of view.
You may refer to relevant historical information not mentioned in the sources.
1. To what extent did the Silk Road create an interconnected network?
What kinds of additional documentation would help assess the role of the Silk Road in creating interconnected network from the 2nd century C.E. to the 13th century?
THIS SPACE MAY BE USED FOR PLANNING YOUR ANSWER.
Source: Roman historian, Cassius Dio, 164 - 224 C.E., commented on a celebration the Roman emperor, Julius Caesar, staged in his own honor around 50 B.C.E.
If I mention one feature of his [Caesar's] extravagance at that time, I shall thereby give an idea of all the rest. In order that the sun might not annoy any of the spectators, he had curtains stretched over them made of silk, according to some accounts. Now this fabric is a device of barbarian luxury, and has come down from them even to us to gratify the fastidious taste of fine ladies.
Source: Sima Qian, The Records of the Grand Historian, about Zhang Qian, a diplomat who traveled to the court of the Yuezhi for the Han Emperor Wudi, 1st century B.C.E.
Zhang Qian was the first person to bring back a clear account of the Dayuan [present day Krygystan and Uzbekistan].
Anzi [Parthian Persia] is situated several thousand li [a little more than a third of a mile] west of the region of the Great Yuezhi. The people are settled on the land, cultivating the fields and growing rice and wheat. They also make wine out of grapes. ....
Source: Faxian, A Chinese Buddhist Monk's Travels in India and Ceylon, 399 - 411 C.E.
From this place [Central Asia], we traveled southeast, passing by a succession of very many monasteries, with a multitude of monks .... When stranger monks arrive at any monastery, the old residents meet and receive them ....
Source: Anonymous assistant to a Chinese merchant, A Record of Musings On the Eastern Capital, about Hangzhou, capital of the Southern Sung Dynasty, 1235.
During the morning hours, markets extend from Tranquility Gate of the palace all the way to the north and south sides of the New Boulevard. Here we find pearl, jade, talismans, exotic plants and fruits, seasonal catches from the sea, wild game -- all the rarities of the world seem to be gathered here.
Some of the hustlers are students who failed to achieve any literary distinction. Though able to read and write, and play musical instruments and chess, they are not highly skilled in any art. They end up being a kind of guide for young men from wealthy families, accompanying them in their pleasure-seeking activities.
Source: Friar John of Monte Corvino, Letter to the West, one of two letters written to his fellow Franciscans around 1295. John was sent by Pope Nicolas IV to try to make an alliance with the Mongols against the Mamluk rulers of Egypt.
I, Friar John of Monte Corvino, of the Order of Friars Minor, departed from Tauris, a city of the Persians, in the year of the Lord 1291, and proceeded to India. And I remained in the country of India, wherein stands the church of St. Thomas the Apostle, for thirteen months, ....
I proceeded on my further journey and made my way to Cathay, the realm of the emperor of the Mongols who is called the Great Khan. To him I presented the letter of our lord the pope, and invited him to adopt the Catholic faith of our Lord Jesus Christ, but he had grown too old in idolatry. However he bestows kindnesses upon the Christians, and these two years past I am abiding with him.
Source: Marco Polo, The Travels of Marco Polo, a Venetian merchant who may have worked for the Yuan dynasty, the Mongol rulers of China, late 13th century. This excerpt is a description of Hangzhou, a southern city that was part of the Yuan empire.
There are within the city ten principal squares or market places, besides innumerable shops along the streets. .... On the nearer bank ... stand large stone warehouses provided for merchants who arrive from India and other parts with their goods and effects. They are thus situated conveniently close to the market squares. In each of these, three days in every week, from forty to fifty thousand persons come to these markets and supply them with every article that could be desired.
Sharon Cohen is World History Connected's editor for scholarship on teaching and learning in world history. She is an Advanced Placement World History teacher at Springbrook High School in suburban Maryland. From 2002 – 2006, she was on the AP World History Test Development Committee. She can be contacted at email@example.com.
|Home | List Journal Issues | Table of Contents|
|© 2009 by the Board of Trustees of the University of Illinois|